Just so we can all begin to agree on what constitutes the Mega Scales, we need to identify them and name them, so we know what we're referring to --- OK, if we're going to be persnickety about grammar --- so we know to what we're referring .
My proposal ( for all to use without fear of copyright violation ) :
1 inch to the foot --- RJ Scale, for Rod Johnston, who actually produced a commercial line of one inch scale models , before retreating from the model railroad world to his dental practice in Northern Ontario . That works out to one-twelfth full size . This was also made famous as a secondary product line by Little Engines, whose advertisements in popular (non-hobby) publications claiming "Just bolt 'em together" probably lured as many people into the live steam hobby under (let's be honest) false pretenses as any other print material . The best claim to fame for one inch scale currently is that it is utilized extensively in the dollhouse hobby --- both a good point (lots of material for lineside scenery) AND a bad point for its identification with artsy-craftsy miniatures .
1.5 inches to the foot --- LS Scale , for Live Steam, whose one-eighth full size railroad models are --- arguably --- the most popular and widely utilized Mega - Scale . Here's an example of one-eighth scale traction by Bruce Moffatt :
2 inches to the foot --- PS Scale, one-sixth scale, because Mattel , manufacturers of Barbie (Aaaaagh ! ), has established a huge marketing line of toys and dolls in that scale and has undoubtedly copyrighted the name PlayScale, OR DisPlayScale as a takeoff on Mattel's name and on the fact that it makes a spectacular display, if one takes advantage of the benefits conferred by Forced Perspective, O scale background flats, and the wide variety of trackside accessories .
Mr. Parry of the U.K., inventor of Parry's People Movers (PPM), a local transportation medium intended for rural areas and almost-forgotten passenger stops, sitting next to his one-sixth model of a PPM at an industrial exhibition .
and finally ,
3 inches to the foot --- GH Scale , one-fourth scale , named for Gordon Hatch, whose extraordinary models in that size model trolleys (trams) are now located in a museum in Central Saanich, British Columbia, Canada :
Why "Mega-Scale" ? Because everywhere I go in print or on line, so-called G scale (more properly G Gauge) is referred to as "Large Scale" . A pox on what our Scottish cousins might call "wee sma' toys " !
The other restriction that I would like to strongly recommend --- even though it may seem like an imposition on our Live Steam friends who enjoy riding around their giant railway layouts ... and around, and around, and around , is that we stop riding on top of our models in the mega-scales, as it diminishes (in every way) their appeal to most non-hobbyists .
Think amusement park rides .
Think restricted tunnel and bridge heights and clearances .
Think reducing the viewscape of the audience so much as to eliminate any chance of reality ;
Think eliminating the possibility of placing scale rooftop details on any (true) trolley, tram, or heavy-service box cab equipment . Can you spell "CRUNCH" ? and finally,
Eliminate the possibility of utilizing the currently underutilized art (literally) of Forced Perspective which might become a truly saving grace of realism in model railways .
No comments:
Post a Comment